Slow sales of Pre force Palm to cut forecast
Palm revised fiscal 2010 third-quarter revenue to $285 million to $310 million, below company and analyst forecasts. Palm says full 2010 revenue will be “well below” the previously projected range of $1.6 billion to $1.8 billion. Palm’s stock fell more than 19% to $6.53.
“This is a tough blow for Palm,” Gartner analyst Ken Dulaney says.
The Pre received mostly glowing notices upon its arrival in June through Sprint. It was expected to restore Palm’s shine after its flagship Treo smartphones had lost their luster. But the Pre hasn’t become a best seller, nor have the newer Pre Plus and Pixi Plus. Palm unveiled both on the Verizon Wireless network in January.
“Driving consumer adoption of Palm products is taking longer than we anticipated,” CEO Jon Rubinstein said in a statement. He said Sprint and Verizon remain committed, “And we are working closely with them to increase awareness and drive sales.”
It won’t be easy. With Apple, RIM (BlackBerry), Google (Android), Microsoft and others, competition is only getting fiercer. On Palm’s long-term prospects, Dulaney says, “That’s a tough call.”
Not all analysts are ready to write Palm off. “The company is far from down and out,” says Michael Gartenberg, a partner at the Altimeter Group. “It doesn’t take much for a runner to stumble and for someone to gain some momentum.” He says Palm has a decent-size war chest and “tremendous talent,” but that it can’t afford to make many mistakes.
What’s gone wrong? Palm launched Pre with just one U.S. carrier, Sprint, and precious few apps compared with Apple and other rivals. Phone supplies were tight. “You have a small window to make an impact with a new handset,” Standard & Poor’s analyst James Moorman says.
Dulaney thinks Palm must come out with a new touch-screen-only device and persuade developers to write apps for its WebOS operating system. “I hope the best for them,” he says. “Palm is one of the hallmarks of Silicon Valley.”